
GARRET MEADE PHOTO | Southoldâs Alex Poliwoda sliding safely under Shelter Island shortstop Hunter Starzee and kicking up a dust cloud.
FIRST SETTLERS 3, INDIANS 1
The same instinct that tells Southoldâs baseball coach, Mike Carver, when to call for a bunt or a hit-and-run, told him that something was up.
After Fridayâs game, Carver was trailing his players as they marched from their Southold High School field to the gym. Then, one of his players, Anthony Esposito, lugging a large, apparently empty water bucket with him, tracked back to the field, past Carver, saying he forgot something on the bench. While Carver and the rest of the First Settlers stopped and waited for him, Esposito walked back to the bench, picked up a package of crackers and then returned Carverâs way. With the coach eyeing him suspiciously, Esposito suddenly hurled water that had been in the bucket at Carver, who quickly jumped aside so that only some of the water hit him.
As far as Gatorade baths go, it wasnât the best, but it was the spirit behind the subterfuge that counted.
The First Settlers had their own way of celebrating Carverâs 150th career win, a 3-1 victory over Shelter Island that moved them a step closer to the playoffs in the process.
âIt was just a last-minute thing,â Southold third baseman Alex Poliwoda said. âWe kept a little bit of water in the water bucket and said, âWe should get him with this.â Heâs got to expect it. It was a great win, 150.â
The Suffolk County Baseball Coaches Association will recognize the milestone with a plaque for Carver, whose 12-year record is 150-102 (.595). Prior to the start of this season, Carver ranked 14th among the countyâs active coaches in wins.

GARRET MEADE PHOTO | Southold second baseman Sean Moran backhanded this ground ball but was unable to make a play on it.
âItâs a nice accomplishment,â Carver, 40, said. âItâs a nice milestone. Iâm real proud of what we, the team, the boys over the years have accomplished with Southold baseball. Iâm proud of that. Itâs definitely a sign that we had success. We have had success. Without the players, we wouldnât have any wins.â
The win on Friday, Southoldâs sixth straight, did the teamâs playoff chances a world of good. The First Settlers (9-5, 9-5 League IX) need two wins from their final six regular-season games (three each against Smithtown Christian and Greenport) in order to clinch a postseason place.
âWeâre in a great position right now,â Poliwoda said. He said the teamâs playoff scenario is âdoable, so I feel pretty confident.â
Rob Mahony (2-2) turned in the complete-game win with eight strikeouts. He allowed six hits and three walks.
The First Settlers scratched out the win with the aid of two runs in the third inning. Three successive doubles by Noah Mina, Anthony Fedele and Poliwoda brought in those runs for a 3-0 lead.
Southold had opened the scoring in the first. Poliwoda led off with a single, stole second base and, after two walks, came home on a fielderâs choice by Dillon Engels.
Shelter Islandâs sole run came in the fourth. Hunter Starzee, who led off by shooting a single to right field, stole second base and advanced to third on a single by Matt BeltCappellino. Then Starzee scored when a fly ball by Spencer Gibbs was misplayed in the outfield for the gameâs only error.
Shelter Islandâs leadoff hitter, Riley Willumsen, produced three singles.
The Indians, who returned to varsity baseball after five straight years of junior varsity ball, dropped to 2-12, 2-12 with their sixth loss in a row.
Shelter Island coach Peter Miedema said the move back to the varsity level on Shelter Island brought some excitement as well as a little ânervousnessâ among his players. Although the core of the team is made up of juniors, he said, âWe had to take some eighth-graders and some ninth-graders, and thatâs a scary thought to go from a junior high to a varsity level.â
âBatting-wise, itâs tough for us to put together six, seven good at-bats in a row,â Miedema said. âThe pitching has improved ⊠and the defense has improved immensely. Hopefully the wins come eventually.â
The progress was evident on Friday. Absent were the handful of errors that the Indians have been known to make in a game (they had none Friday). BeltCappellino (1-5) gave up five hits before being relieved by Gibbs with two out in the fourth.
âWe knew we werenât going to be that good [this season], but itâs a little tougher than we expected,â Willumsen said. âWeâre still working on a lot of things that we have to work out, but weâre getting better.â
Carverâs big day clearly meant something to his players.
âIt just feels great to be part of the history of Southold baseball,â Poliwoda said. âYou know, being part of his 150th win, we all did it together. It just feels great to be part of that.â